Competition identity
A drawn league match and a drawn cup tie have different consequences
In a league, a drawn match can be the completed result. In a knockout cup, a club must advance. The competition chooses the authorized procedure for that decision. The Laws of the Game allow methods; they do not make every organizer use the same combination.
Begin with the competition, season and round. The same two clubs can meet in a league game and a cup tie, and a level score at the end of ordinary playing time can lead to different next steps.
The FA Cup proper no longer uses the old replay route
The FA announced the removal of replays throughout the competition proper from 2024/25, extending the previous later-round policy. A current first-round-proper or later tie should not be described with an old rule that expects another match after a draw.
Qualifying rounds must be distinguished from the competition proper. A historical replay is also a real past fixture under the rules then used; it should not be rewritten as a current procedural example. The current season’s FA rules remain the definitive source.
The German cup also requires a winner on the day
The DFB’s published Pokal explanation gives thirty minutes of extra time, in two fifteen-minute periods, if ninety minutes has produced no winner. Penalties follow if the teams remain level. The cup does not turn that draw into a new home-and-away aggregate tie.
The DFB-Pokal is distinct from Bundesliga promotion/relegation playoffs, which use two legs. Sharing German clubs does not make the two competitions use the same deciding structure.
Extra-time goals and shoot-out kicks are recorded differently
Extra time continues the match, so its goals are part of the match score. A shoot-out is the subsequent deciding process and its kicks should be listed separately. Adding the two produces a misleading result.
A hypothetical match at 1–1 after extra time, with a 5–4 shoot-out, is not a 6–5 ordinary score. The full listing should preserve both the match result and the shoot-out outcome so a reader can see how advancement was decided.
Leave room for the deciding sequence
A ninety-minute playing period is not a promise of a ninety-minute programme. Stoppage time, extra time and deciding kicks can extend the contest. A recording that ends at the regulation score can omit the actual outcome.
For an archived cup match, retain the round and year and check whether the programme includes extra time or the shoot-out where applicable. For a current rules question, use the actual organizer’s document rather than assuming this two-competition explanation also governs every French, Scottish or continental cup.
Questions answered
Does every current FA Cup proper draw create a replay?
No. The FA removed those replays from 2024/25.
Does a DFB-Pokal draw create a two-leg aggregate tie?
No. Its published procedure uses extra time and, if required, penalties.
Are shoot-out kicks added to the ordinary match goals?
No. Record the shoot-out separately.
Sources & further reading
Official references for the subjects discussed. Service terms and device software can change.